If anyone on either side of la mer Atlantique is truly “shocked, shocked” that Pierre de Villiers has been maneuvered into resigning as chef de l’armee de France, s/he can never again credibly claim any standing as a connaisseur of French cultural discourse and politics. Beneath the surface patina of policy differences and budget contraction, here’s what Macron‘s tempête de théière with de Villiers really means: more than merely a two-fer, more than a three-fer, it’s a four-fold declaration of defiant independence.
— an implicit critique of Donald Trump;
— an outright rebuke of Vladimir Putin;
— a conciliatory gesture toward the Muslim world, especially the Maghreb and the Gulf states;
— a coup de poing maçonique directed at the institutional and cultural influence of the Roman Catholic church in France.
The simultaneity of all these unmixed messages is made possible because of the existence of one man: Pierre de Villiers’ frère, Philippe. How so? Because in many ways, Philippe de Villiers is a French (and thus somewhat classier) version of Donald Trump. He’s a conservative nationalist entrepreneur-turned-politician whose worldview is based in (and biased by) his Catholic faith. He has achieved notoriety in Europe (and throughout the Mediterranean region beyond) for his strident criticism of Islam and the purported threat it poses to “European” culture. He consorts with billionaire Russian kleptocrats like Konstantin Malofeev, and in 2014 traveled to newly-annexed Crimea, where he met with Vladimir Putin to advocate development of a joint-venture Crimean theme park designed to “promote the history of Crimea as part of the long history of Russia.”
This all sure sounds familiar, but leaves one wondering which of the two –Trump or de Villiers– is the “original” throwback patriarch. Does it really matter? Probably not. Perhaps we should be thinking about who wrote the playbook.
Meanwhile, back at Palais Elysée, by maneuvering brother Pierre into a position where his honor as a warrior/aristocrat required démission, Manny Macron has begun a campaign to diminish Philippe de Villiers’ access to information and key nodes in the social networks that constitute the command structure of French military and intelligence institutions. Friends of François Fillon won’t be far behind. Best of all, those in the know will get the message:
— Trumpisme n’est pas bon
— ni Putinisme
— nous avons besoin de nos amis (riche) Arabes
— l’eglise hors d’ici
Any questions?